Artificial Intelligence in Veterinary Practices: Workflows and More

Artificial Intelligence in Veterinary Practices: Workflows and More

This article examines how artificial intelligence (AI) transforms veterinary practices by enhancing diagnostic workflows, supporting clinical decision-making, and improving patient care. It highlights the integration of AI tools, such as Vetology’s AI Radiology Reports, into various clinical settings, including emergency, general, and low-cost practices emphasizing the value of AI in providing rapid, consistent analyses, reducing clinician workload and fostering confidence in diagnostic decisions. Read more about how:

  • AI assists in confirming diagnoses swiftly, especially in emergency settings.
  • It streamlines workflows by reviewing radiographs and prioritizing cases.
  • AI tools enhance diagnostic value in cost-effective practices.
  • They provide reassurance for new graduates handling complex cases.

Q&A: Artificial Intelligence

How AI Can Help Practices of All Kinds

Written by Sarah McNeal

Artificial intelligence seems new, because of ChatGPT. And by now, many people have experimented with it either for generating images or illustrations, or to help with writing prompts. But AI has been used in radiology for a while. Patterson Teleradiology powered by Vetology AI is built on thousands of cases, with AI reports returned in under five minutes. It’s ideal for many types of practices to confirm suspicions, act as a second opinion or illustrate for clients what issue their pet is facing. Each case submitted comes with a full report that can be emailed or printed for transparency with clients.

Insight asked Staci Thorne, CVT about how artificial intelligence can help today’s busy practices. Thorne is a certified vet tech with more than 20 years of experience, including emergency clinics.

Can AI Be Trusted?

Short answer, yes!

Longer answer: In the same way that you would trust your CBC or urine sediment analyzer to aid you in your diagnostic process, AI in radiology can be trusted as a useful tool to help confirm your diagnosis. AI is all about data, and as we continue to feed it more and more information, its uses and capabilities become sharper and stronger. The software’s machine learning algorithms have been exposed to thousands and thousands of radiographs over many years and all those data points have helped build the neural networks that make those platforms so powerful.

Q: In which types of clinics does it work best and why?
Vetology has a use case in many clinical settings that I can think of:

  • Are you an ER that needs some diagnostic answers immediately?
    Use AI to confirm that your patient needs treatment within minutes.
  • Are you a general practice that wants to reduce the workload and simplify workflow?
    AI can review every radiograph and determine which ones need to be sent for further evaluation, freeing up your time to focus on other things.
  • Are you a low-cost practice with high standard of care?
    Use AI to evaluate all your radiographs and receive a shareable report back that enhances your diagnostic value and reserves teleradiology costs for those cases that truly need it.
  • Are you a new grad looking for that extra bit of reassurance for difficult-to-read cases?
    Confirm your suspicions with AI.

Originally published in:
Insight Companion Animal Edition, July 2024, Patterson Veterinary

Artificial Intelligence in Clinical Radiology

Artificial Intelligence in Clinical Radiology

Veterinary Innovation Podcast
Episode 68 – Dr. Seth Wallack | Vetology

Join the clever minds behind the Veterinary Innovation Podcast – Shawn Wilkie, CEO of Talkatoo and Dr. Ivan Zak, CEO of Veterinary Integration Solutions – as we discuss veterinary radiology with our own Dr. Seth Wallack, DACVR.

One of the largest issues in veterinary radiology today is an incredibly high caseload. Radiologists in North America consult on 2.5 million cases per year, and that number is projected to more than double within the next three years. With fewer educational opportunities available in radiology, how can this vital specialization keep up with the demand?

This week on the Veterinary Innovation Podcast, Shawn and Ivan speak with Dr. Seth Wallack, the founder and CEO of Vetology, about how artificial intelligence can improve the workflow of clinical radiologists, whether we’re too late in adopting it, and how the best veterinarians are those who are most eager to learn.

Topics Covered in the Conversation

  • The shrinking number of Radiologists and how AI can fill those gaps.
  • The adoption of new technologies in clinical radiology.
  • Higher amounts of specialization in veterinary medicine.

More from this podcast and Episode: Click to read more

I

Listen to the Podcast

This Podcast is available on all popular podcast streaming services.

Innovations in The Use of AI Veterinary Radiology Products

Innovations in The Use of AI Veterinary Radiology Products

As technology rapidly advances, AI veterinary radiology products are reshaping the field of veterinary medicine. These innovations offer new opportunities for veterinary practices to enhance diagnostics and care. In this article you will learn how:
  • AI enhances veterinary radiology for quicker, precise imaging assessments.
  • Wearable devices will revolutionize pet health monitoring and care.
  • Combining AI with human expertise ensures better patient outcomes.
  • AI-driven consultations reduce wait times and improve diagnostic accuracy.
  • Developments AI in veterinary medicine are paving the way for personalized medicine and genomics.

The implementation of artificial intelligence in the field of veterinary radiology allows doctors to receive crucial diagnostic information almost immediately.

The world of medicine is constantly changing, and the veterinary medical field is no different. Technology is advancing rapidly, and the rule is to adapt to these changes or succumb to the consequences. The use of artificial intelligence (AI) in veterinary radiology is a relatively new area. Leaders in this field are ethically responsible for providing correct product knowledge to the veterinary community, and should follow the principles of transparency, honesty, and integrity. At the same time, veterinary professionals eager to use this new technology must understand that the field is ever-evolving. As such, offered products will be in different development stages. Good Machine Learning Practices (GMLP) should be adhered to and documented.1

AI in veterinary medicine – potential areas of impact

Implementing an artificial intelligence strategy is a must for veterinary practices moving into the future. Access to specialists is not always available to hospitals or clients, and AI offers an attractive solution. However, experts believe that depending solely on AI can be detrimental. A strategic combination of both human competency and AI technology is important to drive the best care.

Some of the products related to AI in veterinary practice have already been in the marketplace for years. These are expected to gain immense popularity in the near future. The market for global wearable devices for the remote monitoring of pet health and activity is forecast to reach over $8 billion by year 2025.

When it comes to the human health market, similar products have gained in popularity. These are known for measuring simple parameters such as movement, heart rate, and body temperature. In addition, these devices keep tabs on food intake. They will make recommendations based on appropriate behavioral responses. For instance, these devices will inform diabetic patients about requirements for glucose or insulin.

New devices with the capability of measuring other important parameters will soon be available. In the veterinary field, cattle can be fitted with movement sensors to identify the onset of estrus. Similar technology will no doubt become available for other species, including pigs. At present, these sensors are quite expensive, especially for routine usage. Special efforts are being made to produce low-cost versions of the technology that would make them more accessible to farming operations.

This process will emulate the rapid decrease in the cost of genome analysis, resulting in possible developments of custom-made medicines in animals and human patients. Apart from identifying individuals with genotypes that may make them more or less vulnerable to the effects of specific drugs, professionals will also carry out genomic analyses on microbiome samples from the skin, gut, and other sites to evaluate which disease-causing organisms may exist in the patient’s body. There have been speculations on whether these approaches will ultimately lead to a reduction in the demand for antibiotics.

Advancements in monitoring technologies will similarly lead to challenges in processing and applying the available data. It is believed that doctors will have access to 200 times more data than the human mind can process. Consequently, another priority is the development of artificial intelligence software that analyzes this mass of information and draws precise conclusions about its meaning.

Google and Apple have special teams working on these issues. Significant development has already been seen; a team has produced diagnostic software that can easily identify human patients with early indications of diabetes. It is based on constant measurements of heart rate variation. This technology and others will change the way clinical practice operates.

Current applications

1. Medical imaging processing and assessment

The use of AI in this area includes quick yet precise and sensitive interpretations of radiographs, MRI images, CT scans, ultrasound images, and cytology assessments. At present, all aspects of AI are progressing exponentially, from computer processing power, speed, and affordability, to the development of machine vision reference directories. Hence, it is expected that most standard tasks involving clinical interpretation in veterinary practice will be allotted to AI. This will help veterinarians obtain quick, accurate, and detailed reports as well as consistency in interpretation, a factor that currently depends on the experience and skill level of the individual practitioner.

2. First-line primary consultations

This is another area where AI shows enormous potential. For human patients, smart kiosks are available that cut down on wait times, a major source of dissatisfaction among patients and stress for physicians. However, a combination of AI and detailed AR (augmented reality) instructions ensures a consistent, accurate, and detailed collection of crucial patient history and physical examination data. This is provided and collected by the patients themselves while they are guided through the entire procedure. After collecting the relevant data (usually completed in under 15 minutes), the doctor is sent a detailed patient work-up that includes a proper breakdown of predicted illnesses and treatment options. The medical practitioner then conducts a video consultation in order to confirm the authenticity of the AI-collected information, verify the diagnosis, and approve or alter the treatment plan. AI will also help maintain detailed and accurate healthcare records, and will automatically follow up with patients within a few days of the consultation.

Special efforts are being made to roll out veterinary-related versions of this system. Experts in the field believe that this technology will significantly augment the experience of clients and their pets. Implementation of this technology will also improve the professional lives of veterinarians, who face similar issues of stress and overload as their human physician counterparts.

Using artificial intelligence software provides an attractive option for all doctors, allowing them to receive crucial diagnostic information almost immediately.

Author disclosure statement: Eric Goldman is President of Vetology AI, a company that designs and delivers service innovation for the veterinary industry. He has a financial interest in Vetology Innovations LLC. For more information visit vetology.ai.

 

_______________________________

 

1American Association of Veterinary Radiologists guidelines, submission and review process for Veterinary Radiology Artificial Intelligence (AI) AAVR GMLP SaMD Product Certification— American Association of Veterinary Radiologists.

Artificial Intelligence in Veterinary Medicine

Artificial Intelligence in Veterinary Medicine

This article examines how artificial intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing veterinary medicine by enhancing diagnostic accuracy, improving workflow efficiency, and addressing the shortage of radiologists. It highlights Vetology’s AI-driven tools, such as automated radiograph analysis and teleradiology services, which support veterinarians in making timely and informed decisions. It emphasizes the importance of integrating AI with human expertise to ensure optimal patient care and operational effectiveness. Read more about how:

  • AI accelerates radiograph interpretation, reducing turnaround times.
  • Automated analysis aids in detecting abnormalities and guiding treatment plans.
  • Teleradiology services provide access to board-certified radiologists remotely.
  • Combining AI with human oversight enhances diagnostic confidence and accuracy.

Can machine learning live up to expectations?

The American Medical Veterinary Association (AVMA) interviewed Dr. Seth Wallack, Founder of Vetology and Eric Goldman, President of Vetology.

We discussed with the AVMA the challenges of not having enough radiologists to meet the demand. This is not just a problem for our teleradiology practice, but a global problem that impacts general practice managers, specialty and emergency hospitals. Turn-around times for obtaining a radiology over-read by a boarded radiologist can take upwards of 8 hours to 5 days. A 2018 study predicted that, by the end of 2022, 66 percent of the North American veterinary teleradiology caseload will not be met.

Vetology recognized the power of AI technology to automatically read images and interpret results. In 2017, Vetology developed software to use visual object resolution to help diagnose diseases. The techniques were first used internally to support our own radiologists to be more efficient and meet demand. In 2018, the capabilities were expanded and we were the first to market to offer an augmented interpretation of radiographs using artificial intelligence and machine learning. This allowed for a complete radiograph interpretation in 5 minutes or less and on par to that of a human veterinary radiologist.

The AVMA identified that artificial intelligence has the ability to speed up radiology interpretations and provides a substantial benefit to both patient health and the DVM. Faster, more reliable results mean faster diagnoses, better treatment, and healthier pets.

Read the full article on the AVMA website

Artificial intelligence & veterinary medicine

Can machine learning live up to expectations?

How Intelligent Is Artificial Intelligence?

How Intelligent Is Artificial Intelligence?

This article examines how to assess the effectiveness of artificial intelligence (AI) in veterinary radiology by focusing on clinical performance metrics such as sensitivity and specificity. It emphasizes the importance of evaluating AI tools using confusion matrix tables, which compare AI results against veterinary radiologist reports.  It also highlights the necessity for AI systems to operate autonomously to ensure valid results. Read more about how:

  • Sensitivity measures the AI’s ability to correctly identify patients with a condition.
  • Specificity assesses the AI’s accuracy in identifying patients without a condition.
  • Confusion matrix tables provide a detailed comparison of AI and radiologist assessments.
  • Autonomous AI systems are crucial for reliable diagnostic outcomes.

AI For Human And Veterinary Radiology

Radiology Artificial Intelligence, commonly referred to as AI, is in full development, and the FDA is actively testing AI in human radiology. In veterinary radiology we’re not far behind and are quickly catching up. Veterinary medicine AI product development’s greatest strength is also its greatest weakness. That is, oversight, or more specifically, the lack of oversight by a governing body.

In human radiology, AI products require FDA oversight and approval prior to coming to market (see the American Association of Veterinary Radiologists GMLP write-up here to learn more. Some veterinary products do fall under FDA oversight, BUT veterinary radiology AI isn’t one of them. This means a veterinary radiology AI company can develop quickly, but also has no formal obligation to demonstrate that its product actually works.

If a company doesn’t provide clinical test results, it is up to you, the veterinarian, to determine the worthiness of the product. A true ‘caveat emptor.’

Assessment Is Critical

So how should a veterinarian assess a veterinary radiology AI product? The same way the entire medical community evaluates any diagnostic test for a condition, by measuring clinical performance.

The two standard measures of clinical performance are SENSITIVITY and SPECIFICITY.

To better understand how these measures can assist us to asses clinical performance, we will briefly revisit a couple of formulas from that old favorite – statistics class.

Sensitivity And Specificity

SENSITIVITY is the probability that a test will identify a patient who HAS a condition (true positive). It is calculated by the following formula:

formula: sensitivity = true positives/(true positives + false negatives)
formula: specificity = true negatives/(true negatives + false positives)

SPECIFICITY is the probability a test will correctly identify a patient who DOES NOT have a condition (true negative). It is calculated by the following formula:

The Confusion Matrix

These two standard measures of clinical performance lead us to the four outcomes possible for each patient:

True Positive  |  False Positive  |  True Negative  |  False Negative

The four outcomes are typically reported in a 2 x 2 table called a confusion matrix, showing the total numbers of true and false positives and negatives. A generic example is shown here next.

A Typical Confusion Matrix

Name of Condition or Disease

Total Number of Cases Measured

% Sensitivity

% Specificity

Radiologist Positive Radiologist Negative
AI Positive # of cases # of cases
AI Negative # of cases # of cases

Vetology’s AI Testing

Vetology’s AI testing evaluates AI results against veterinary radiologist reports as a reference standard. The results and confusion matrix tables are displayed just below on this page.

The Truth Is In The Confusion Matrix

To help you evaluate a product’s performance, always ask an AI vendor for their confusion matrix tables.

Also, be aware that an AI product MUST be 100% autonomous to have a valid result. If a human intervenes during any part of the result creation, it’s not artificial intelligence, it’s human intelligence.

Next we show the confusion matrix for several diseases among 75 random cases:

Cardiomegaly

47 Cases

90% Sensitivity

76% Specificity

Radiologist Positive Radiologist Negative
AI Positive 17 19
AI Negative 3 8

Heart Failure

39 Cases

100% Sensitivity

89% Specificity

Radiologist Positive Radiologist Negative
AI Positive 3 4
AI Negative 0 32

Dynamic Airway Pattern

30 Cases

100% Sensitivity

85% Specificity

Radiologist Positive Radiologist Negative
AI Positive 3 4
AI Negative 0 23

Dynamic Airway Collapse

30 Cases

67% Sensitivity

93% Specificity

Radiologist Positive Radiologist Negative
AI Positive 2 2
AI Negative 1 25

Buyers Beware

As we said earlier in this article, AI brings to the forefront of your purchase decision-making, the phrase ‘caveat emptor,’ or buyer beware. Make sure you review the provider’s confusion matrix tables (if they have them at all), and make sure their AI is fully autonomous, else you’ll just be buying expensive human intelligence.

At Vetology, we assertively and proactively test ourselves and continually train and improve the AI for everyone’s benefit. We are as transparent as possible. We have the data and are willing to publish it.

If you have any questions about our veterinary radiology software or services, we encourage you to contact us..

Pin It on Pinterest